Compare the full stay, not the headline rate
A hotel quote and a vacation rental quote can describe very different purchases. Start with matching dates, guest counts, and sleeping arrangements, then enter the hotel tax separately from its nightly rate. For the rental, collect the cleaning charge and the service fee from the final checkout screen. Those fixed charges matter most on short stays because they are spread across fewer nights, even when the advertised rental rate looks attractive.
For a useful worked comparison, keep a copy of the quotes you used and record exactly what is included. Rental taxes must already be in its rate or fees. Recheck the final payment screen before committing, since a headline price may omit a charge that changes your decision. Use the result to identify the items worth verifying, then update the inputs with confirmed amounts rather than treating an early estimate as a final invoice.
Treat cooking savings as a budget credit
Cooking savings should reflect what your group would actually avoid spending, after buying groceries. If breakfast is included at the hotel, do not count the full cost of breakfast as a rental benefit. The rental adjusted total subtracts this estimated saving from the accommodation bill for comparison purposes. You still pay the rental host the full quoted amount, and an unusually large food credit can produce a negative adjusted budget figure.
Try a second scenario before making your decision. Cooking savings are for the entire group per day. Change one uncertain assumption at a time so you can see which detail has the largest effect on the result. If a small change reverses your preference, keep some room in your budget or schedule rather than relying on the most optimistic case. Save the assumptions alongside the result so everyone in your travel group understands what the comparison does and does not include.

